Georgetown study measures colleges’ return on investment : NPR

NPR’s Elissa Nadworny speaks with Martin Van Der Werf, director of editorial and training coverage at Georgetown’s Heart on Schooling and the Workforce, about their new faculty rankings.


Goes to school value it? That is the query researchers from Georgetown College’s Heart on Schooling and the Workforce are attempting to reply. To take action, they’ve crunched new federal knowledge on commencement charges, scholar debt and the way a lot graduates earn in an effort to rank 4,500 schools and universities.

Martin Van Der Werf is a type of Georgetown researchers, and he joins me now. Welcome, Martin.

MARTIN VAN DER WERF: Thanks for having me.

NADWORNY: So is that this a brand new mind-set about the place to go to school? I do know for a very long time, these selections have been actually emotional or, you realize, made by sort of the place your neighbor went. What’s new about this pondering?

VAN DER WERF: Properly, I feel the thought of the place to go to school nonetheless is fairly emotional.


VAN DER WERF: The important thing in regards to the scorecard knowledge, it is the primary time that we have had this type of knowledge about how a lot folks make 10 years and 40 years after they enroll in faculty, knowledge on the sorts of mortgage debt that the common scholar might need, knowledge on commencement charges, and now it is freely accessible to the general public.

You realize, you concentrate on the main selections that we make in our lives, and faculty is correct up there with, say, shopping for a automobile and shopping for a home. You realize, once you purchase a home, you take a look at it, you tour it, you take a look at comps, you get a reasonably good thought of what you are getting. However with regards to faculty, you form of do not know what you are getting. It is sort of a black field. And this actually is the primary time that you’ve got been in a position to have a look at what would possibly occur because of attending a particular establishment and majoring in a particular main.

NADWORNY: Let’s dive into that cash query, actually. I imply, do faculty grads earn extra? What are you seeing sort of throughout issues that you simply research throughout establishments?

VAN DER WERF: Generally, going to school pays off. However it solely pays off when you end. It does not repay when you do not. And it might repay at completely different ranges. It is not simply the bachelor’s diploma, for instance. In the event you earn an affiliate’s diploma, it does repay within the market.

What does not repay is individuals who go after which take out loans after which do not end. After which they’re even additional behind the eight ball than if they’d by no means gone in any respect.

NADWORNY: Is there a class or a sort of faculty or college the place simply throughout the board you see a very excessive return on funding?

VAN DER WERF: Properly, we occurred to seek out out that schools that focus very narrowly on specialised medical functions like pharmacy colleges have very excessive payoffs. We additionally discover typically that schools which have excessive STEM populations additionally are likely to have very excessive payoffs.

NADWORNY: Conversely, do you see a sort of faculty or college the place the return on funding is persistently low?

VAN DER WERF: For-profit establishments that is likely to be specializing in sort of the new matter of the day – for instance, designing video games or different occupations associated to IT. However what we discover is that quite a lot of the credentials that they have been providing, by the point a scholar finishes, the market could have already overtaken it. They’re outdated they usually’re now not wanted or required by employers. So that you must be very, very cautious about establishments like that.

NADWORNY: So there may be a lot data right here for households. It may be actually complicated. Is there a greater strategy to be serving to college students and households make these selections?

VAN DER WERF: I feel that schools actually need to have interaction with households on this dialog and speak to them about what the potential outcomes are going to be. I additionally suppose that on this nation, we want a extra complete system of counseling that actually talks about choices. You will have completely different occupations, completely different majors, other ways of going about pursuing the profession that folks think about for themselves. And we simply do not have an actual good system of that proper now. Counselors would possibly actually be capable to assist us to know what our choices are higher than we will perceive ourselves.

NADWORNY: That is Martin Van Der Werf, from Georgetown College. Thanks a lot.

VAN DER WERF: Thanks to your curiosity in our work.

Copyright © 2022 NPR. All rights reserved. Go to our web site phrases of use and permissions pages at for additional data.

NPR transcripts are created on a rush deadline by an NPR contractor. This textual content will not be in its last kind and could also be up to date or revised sooner or later. Accuracy and availability could range. The authoritative file of NPR’s programming is the audio file.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.